God inspired various people to write the bibletorah. Top atheist and apologist to debate does god exist. For example, i had a debate several years ago and franklin and marshall college in pennsylvania with paul kurtz, the famous humanist philosopher, on the topic. He is a metaphysically necessary being, a being whose nature is such that if he is possible, then he exists. Kai nielsen born 1926 is professor emeritus of philosophy at the university of calgary.
Biola university is a nationally ranked private evangelical christian university located in southern california, and a member of the coalition for christian colleges and universities. Con needs to provide solid evidence for the existence of. Dec 06, 2012 three out of five scientists do not believe in god, but two out of five do, said john donvan, opening a debate on the issue of science and religion wednesday in new york. This requires that the universe does not exist by the necessity of its own nature, and that anything that could possibly exist outside the universe, could not be the cause of the. Following the debate are new essays by prominent scholars.
Few things are more absurd than the current debate over the existence of god. Regardless of which view you hold, the genesis debate is a powerful read for anyone interested in the creation debate. Book reproduces debate on suffering, morality and existence. Jan 28, 2014 if i had to choose a single book on debating, i would suggest thank you for arguing. But we shouldnt imagine that will settle the god vs science debate, says graham farmelo. What aristotle, lincoln and homer simpson can teach us about the art of persuasion by jay heinreichs expanded and revised edition published in august 20. As we are going to discuss the existence of god, it might perhaps be as well to come to some provisional agreement as to what we understand by the term god.
At this epic event, hitchens, a devoted atheist and author of the bestselling god is not great, will square off with one of the most formidable debaters in the christian. Does god exist debate successful and encourages dialogue more than 10,000 viewed biola universitys apologetics event saturday, april 4, 2009. Hitchens, richard dawkins, my friend william lobdell and others who have once again put at the center of the public stage the question of whether or not god does exist and. Debate now does it make sense to accept gods existence. April 4th, 2009 a brilliant debate at biola university about whether god exists, between christopher hitchens and william lane craig. The refusal of richard dawkins to debate william lane craig has attracted criticism from other atheists, one of whom has said it is apt to be interpreted as cowardice. In this rousing debate before a largely secular audience, dr. The most advanced computer software has the human mind as its creator. Confronting the irrationality of the new atheism kregel, 2014. Does god exist a dialogue between a christian and an atheist. Book reproduces debate on suffering, morality and existence of god vienna, w. Find out more about what sets talbot apart and how it prepares. A note on the craighitchens debate psychology today.
Hitchens is world famous for his book god is not great, and eloquently represents new atheism. Does god exist the craigflew debate by william lane. Ive always eagerly read, listen, and disucussed this very serious matter of ultimate questions. Debate now does it make sense to accept god s existence based solely on the arguments presented for it discussion in debate now structured discussion forum started by 320 years of history, nov 4, 2015. The thought of a thing came here and created us gave us the knowledge. A good evangelistic tract for the intelligent seeker.
Christopher hitchens debates william lane craig at biola u. Does god exist is a vital resource for anyone who doubts the christian faith, or seeks convincing evidence to defend it. I am very excited to be participating in this debate tonight. The craigflew debate william lane craig and antony flew met on the 50th anniversary of the famous coplestonrussell debate to discuss the question of god s existence. Dembski the existence of god good morning and thanks for this opportunity to debate the existence and goodness of god. This book is the transcript of a 1988 debate that took place at old miss oxford, mississippi just 30 miles from where my mother lives. Unlike many books of this sort, kreefts introduction aids the reader into the debate and if one is new to the questions of philosophy, the background provided become even more important. I presume that we mean a supreme personal being distinct from the world and creator of the world. The silly debate over gods existence thank god for evolution.
According to the video of debate, dawkins say that god is merely an illusion and god does not exist. Stein was a fairly well known atheist in the mid 80s, writing numerous books and having various public debates. The two men represented the cream of the intellectual crop. Wc would you agree that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. They assert that those divinely inspired books say god exists. Dawkins refuses god debate with william lane craig. On april 4, 2009, william lane craig and christopher hitchens met at biola university to debate the question of god s existence. The answer in my book is, we cannot prove it because what does not exist is not perceptible to the human mind and therefore beyond proof in the context of the meaning of the word proof. Wc ok give me an argument for the claim you just made to know god does not exist. Craig defends arguments for god s existence against naturalistic objections, and presses naturalist john shook to provide a cogent argument for naturalism by exposing the weak points in shooks. On april 4, 2009, more than 4,000 people will watch as christopher hitchens and william lane craig debate does god exist. Isnt it reasonable to think that a all powered thing is fake, he is all knowing and understands every emotion perfectly. If you could reason with religious people, there would be no religious people. A 21st century guide for atheists and believers and everyone in between by john r.
There sinnottarmstrong opened by arguing against the existence of god, and then craig criticized sinnottarmstrongs arguments and offered argu. During the christian book expo in dallas last month, craig and hitchens took opposing sides in a panel examining does the god of christianity exist, and. Richard dawkins vesves christopher hitchens debate the best documentary ever duration. Its only reasonable we are smart creations and we do. He knows that i am a christian, and since the topic shifted toward values and ethics, i began asking him questions about his beliefs on the existence of subjective and objective values based on the premises that 1. Does god exist or not exist the great debate dante urbina. I purchased this dvd in december of 2011 and have watched it three times. Moreland is distinguished professor of philosophy at talbot school of theology, biola university. So the explanation of god s existence must be internal to him, that is to say, god exists by a necessity of his own nature. There is about 6 billion religious people, you cant say that all of them are that crazy that they belive in nothing. William craig and antony flew met on the 50th anniversary of the famous coplestonrussell debate to discuss the question of god s existence in a public debate. Does god exist debate successful and encourages dialogue.
Does god exist william lane craig debates christopher. Before continuing, i need to remind you of the fundamental distinction between the objective and t. This book presents the most recent debates by leading contemporary philosophers of enduring themes and issues concerning the question of god s existence. The layout follows a common format for debate type books. Prior to an evolutionary worldview, such debates made sense.
Renowned apologist and atheist debate does god exist. These essays comment on the debate and advance the broader discussion of religion and morality. Ill start by addressing gods existence and then turn to gods goodness. God is neither good nor evil the terms good and evil do not apply to an omnipotentomniscient deity who answers to no higher authority. Books reflections on the explanatory power of theism in does god exist. Jan 10, 2014 debate between dante urbina theist and luis arbaiza representative of the peruvian association of atheists, held at the faculty of arts and human science. A note on the craighitchens debate the attempt to prove the existence of god fails again. Like pretty much every debate, an argument is an explosion caused by the collision of egos. A classic debate on the existence of god books store. Kurtz defends the affirmative position and craig the negative. Bill cooke of the new zealand association of rationalists and humanists and imran aijaz of the auckland university islamic society. Arguments for and against the existence of god are productive. John porter moreland born 1948 is professor of philosophy at talbot school of theology at biola university. One reader of an early draft of this chapter complained at this point, saying that by treating the hypothesis of god as just one more scientific hypothesis, to be evaluated by the standards of science in particular and rational thought in general, dawkins and i are ignoring the very widespread claim by believers in god that their faith is quite beyond reason, not a matter to which such.
The late hitchens was a leading spokesman for the new atheism movement. Preface xi church in eden prairie, minnesota on april 1, 2000. Bahnsen and atheist lawyer former aclu edward tabash at the university of california davis, is a great followup to the bahnsenstein debate. The core of this book contains the edited transcript of that debate. In a similar way, the shiniest human intelligence requires an author. But ultimately i can think of many debates which are more informative and more challenging.
Debating god is the best way for clarifying ways of thinking and challenging conventional beliefs on all sides. Live coverage of the christopher hitchens william lane craig debate on does god exist. If god does not exist, then objective values do not exist. Summary of the william lane craig vs christopher hitchens. Craig takes a departure from special revelation to present the powerful philosophical and scientific evidence for god found in natural theology. Logics proves god s existence, because god s inexistence is an absurdity. Unfortunately, each individual chapter within the book is much too short for anybody to establish much of a case for anything. In an evolutionary context, howeverin light of what ursula goodenough and terry deacon call the sacred emergence of naturesuch arguments are outdated at best. Summary of the william lane craig vs christopher hitchens debate. What if we can imagine a supernatural, god like entity, that is in some important respect distinct from god as. Does god exist debate christopher hitchens vs craig at biola. His theory was fully opposed by lennox who has faith in god. In his lecture, professor eagleton asks why has god sud. I know that god is very cruel, he would kill many people just because they dont believe in him.
He argues that people debate the subject in a circular fashion and use the original bible to prove the point of god s existence. The good book blog, a resource from the faculty of talbot school of theology, features articles that explore contemporary ideas from the perspective of the bible the good book including topics such as apologetics, biblical studies, theology, philosophy, spiritual formation, ministry and leadership. The debate itself was held on the occasion of the fiftieth anniversary of a similarly titled debate between russell and copleston in 1948. Shook the god debates is the evenhanded, accessible philosophical book about the quest of knowledge of god. So we should not say that god chose to exist or to have the essential properties he does. William lane craig, believe that there are solid reasons to believe in god, and during the course of this 2009 debate at biola. In defense of atheism skeptics bookshelf series, etc. Craig is one of the worlds foremost christian apologists. A debate before 4,000 students at the university of wisconsin, madison, on the 50th anniversary of the famous russellcopleston bcc radio debate, reexamining the arguments for and against the existence of god. Debate william lane craig vs christopher hitchens does. To be sure, the debaters were not just lightweight showboats, blowing off steam. God a supreme being responsible for the formation of the universe and what occurs on earth exist is not a figment of humanitys imagination. Hazen introduces moderator hugh hewitt, who outlines the rules for the debate and introduces hitchens and craigcraig.
Feb 17, 2007 emily henochowicz, an 18yearold who denied god with a wry smile in her video, is among those who find the videos an interesting way to talk through the issues of religion and faith. Ive always found it presumptuous and or even insane that one can say god can not exist because an individual from a single point in time tested their one sided one dimensional version of god and that version failed. Bonus features include the pre debate press conference, a question and answer session, and interviews with craig and hitchens. A classic debate on the existence of god a transcript of dr. This twodvd set captures every moment of the debate documented by 10 cameras. Throughout his debate, the 1st strength that we think dawkins had is the fact that he stated that sciences are based on evidence while faith is nothing but trust. Whether or not god exists is a vital question and thats why debates about god are important. Bnc by ron thomas the debate held between ralph gilmore and alexander rosenberg sept. Abel adam and eve ancient angels animals argue babylonian bible biblical book of genesis cain cain and abel cains capital punishment cassuto christian commentary context crea created creation account creationists creative creator deposits divine doctrine e. Ofc there are many against the religion hence why they wont even think about reading these books.
It is the best of timesit is the best of times for those who like to argue about god in the public square, largely because of the rise of new atheists such as mr. Ch i have no argument, but i dont believe in god because it depresses me to think he might be real. Ch i think god does not exist wc ok give me an argument for the claim you just made to know god does not exist ch i have no argument, but i dont believe in god because it. Ignorance about divinity doesnt provide to humans any foundation to deny god s existence. Taking the debate about god online, and battling it out with. Frank turek, coauthor of i dont have enough faith to be an atheist, and christopher hitchens, author of god is not great. Jan and i used to sit in those very bleachers right over there watching our son john run. On january 28, 1948, the bbc brought together two of the centurys brightest minds for a radio debate about the existence of god.
In addition, other scholars contributed their thoughts after the debate and let me say, this is one very heady book. Shook examines the key arguments for god s existence and the atheological responses. Selected writings of a passionate rationalist does god exist. The odds that he does are sufficiently small that we would. Who doesnt like to see a clash of two well known figures regarding such a perennial question as does god exist. For i want you to know how great a struggle i have for you and for those at laodicea and for all who have not seen me face to face, that their hearts may be encouraged, being knit together in love, to reach all the riches of full assurance of understanding and the knowledge of god s mystery, which is. God does whatever he wants and is not constrained by any evaluation of the goodness or evilness of his action. It will make you think and deepen your faith, helping you to see that god not only made the world, and all that is in it, but that he did it by the word of his power, and for his glory. He had an open challenge to debate anyone on the subject of god s existence and even wrote and published a pamphlet titled, how to debate a theist and win i may have the title a bit wrong. Craig, in the leibniz contingency argument, the premise 2 states that if the universe has an explanation of its existence, that explanation is god. Moreland and kai nielsen debate the same topic, but end up talking past eachother most of the time. The evidential value of religious experience in the rationality of theism, ed.
1424 310 1493 849 227 1182 807 839 203 1378 1170 684 1286 1391 1078 885 1312 1253 432 1314 592 827 226 1487 404 994 5 664 240 379 1046 837 1397 707 55 510 1365 748 1119 246 1499 1491 683 1077 741 1395